AGRICULTURE contributes almost a fifth to our
national income annually but its growth has been moribund for years.
Last year’s uptick reported in the recent Economic Survey needs to be
seen in this perspective. It is not a pointer towards sustained growth
but a one-off bounty delivered by nature, which has been somewhat
shrivelled by the crash of commodity prices. Otherwise, the growth
number would have been significant and probably, highlighted as an
indicator of a reviving rural economy by the government.
For the
next year, the budget projects growth in the agriculture sector at
3.9pc. This number is a key input to realise the GDP growth target of
5.5pc set for the economy. Given the sector’s dismal track record, a
concerted effort at all levels to enhance farm productivity will be
required to reach the target. In this scheme, the government has a
pivotal role as its sector interventions, unveiled in the budget, set
the tone for driving other stakeholders including farmers and
agribusinesses to perform.
In the recent budget, three key new
incentives have been announced for the agriculture sector. The first and
second pertain to income tax holidays for businesses investing in the
establishment of cold chains for storage and distribution of perishable
farm products, warehousing of agriculture produce and production
facilities for halal meat. The third relates to reduction of taxes on
local and imported farm machinery and post-harvest equipment for
handling and processing vegetables, fruit and fodder. The thrust is
towards farm mechanisation and curtailment of post-harvest losses which,
for some perishable fruits, can exceed 20pc of total production.
The
question is whether these interventions are going to revive the farm
sector and help the economy achieve its agriculture growth targets set
for the next year.
The first two initiatives have no direct
bearing on productivity enhancement of the farmlands which is critical
for sustainable growth. They will still contribute towards increasing
the farm incomes by limiting post-harvest losses and benefit the economy
by incentivising the corporate sector.
Will the new incentives revive agriculture?
The third initiative has a direct impact on the rural economy but is
likely to benefit large farmers more than small farmers owning less than
12 acres of land. Such farmers constitute more than 80pc of the
country’s farming households and cultivate almost 48pc of the arable
land. But they don’t have surplus resources to invest in farm machinery
and rely on borrowed or hired machines to till their subsistence
holdings.
In terms of an equitable treatment, the budgetary
package offers little relief to the small farmers and also overlooks the
necessity of their contribution in meeting the sector’s growth target.
If their lands don’t deliver more produce, the target can never be
achieved by the rest of the farmlands.
The policy focus on farm
mechanisation is also less meaningful than other possible options,
particularly reduction in input costs of seed, fertiliser and pesticide
as a means to spur agriculture growth. Such interventions would have
been quick in generating results, starting from the crop sown after the
budget’s approval. They could have been targeted at small farmers to
address productivity and equity issues and funded jointly with the
provinces to curtail resource load on the federal exchequer. They would,
however, have entailed cash allocations/outflows, adding to concerns,
shared by the government and the IMF, about overshooting the fiscal
deficit target. They, therefore, did not figure on the priority list of
the budget makers despite their utmost political and economic
significance.
Another reason for not prioritising expenditure on
agriculture is rooted in devolution of this subject to the provinces.
This has fragmented policy formulation and responsibility in a sector
where integration is a necessity for optimal planning based on
comparative advantage of different ecological zones, national food
security concerns and cross-border input and commodity movements and
transactions.
In some ways, the setting of a national target for
agriculture growth after devolution, without ensuring agreement amongst
the federating units on sector priorities and corresponding resource
allocation in their budgets, is a paper endeavour.
The upshot
is that the budgetary measures are unlikely to increase agriculture
growth to the required levels. For this, other stakeholders must
shoulder a greater burden.
In a resource-constrained
situation, the government can ensure productivity gains and growth
through regulatory interventions. It should begin by protecting farmers’
investments in agriculture inputs which have a direct impact on
productivity levels. A campaign to check the sale of spurious seeds,
fertilisers and pesticides, and enforcement of international standards
for quality manufacturing of farm inputs will help improve farm yields.
Otherwise, the economic pundits will have to hope for another plentiful
year in which the domestic prices also escalate to hit the ambitious
growth target.
The writer, a civil servant, has worked in the agriculture sector.
Published in Dawn, June 18th, 2015